How to Detect Modeling Errors with Sparse Solver? | ProtaStructure

How to Detect Modeling Errors with Sparse Solver? | ProtaStructure

The presence of unsupported elements in the structural analysis models causes the formation of mechanisms and the inability to solve the equilibrium equations.

Since singularity occurs in the stiffness matrix of the structure, its determinant becomes zero and the matrix cannot be reversed. Since the traditional Solver solves the equilibrium equation system with the 'Gauss-Jordan Elimination' method and the data is prepared accordingly, it can specify exactly at which node the mechanism formation is. In this case, the program can find the problematic node numbers.

On the other hand, the Sparse equation solver uses different hiding and inverting algorithms to hold and invert symmetric matrix data, which is usually zero, and factorize it. It is faster by the algorithm and has less memory requirement. However, as a disadvantage, it cannot give the exact address of the node where the problem is experienced.

In cases where the problematic node cannot be detected, we can cancel the 'Sparse Equation Solver' and find out which nodes have problems.

The video explains how to proceed in case of a mechanism in the structural analysis model.



    • Related Articles

    • Model Options

      Options to be used in analysis can be specified in “Model Options” page of “Building Analysis” form. “Model Options” comprises of four tab pages namely, Model, Shear Wall Model, Slab Model, and Settings. Any modifications made in this page can be ...
    • Modeling, Analysis, Design & Detailing with ProtaStructure Suite 2022

      ProtaStructure Suite is an all-in-one structural engineering BIM software helping you throughout your project delivery. In this playlist, you can take a quick look at the advanced tools and features of ProtaStructure Suite. Plus, you will discover ...
    • Finite Elements Raft Foundation Analysis

      FE Raft Foundation Analysis is only available at the foundation storey (ST-00). It can be accessed by clicking “ FE Raft Foundation Analysis” from the “ Analysis” tab. Prior to FE Raft Foundation Analysis, it is necessary to complete Building ...
    • ProtaStructure Basic Training Guide

      Thank you for choosing ProtaStructure. This Basic Training Guide aims to get you up and running quickly. Starting from an introduction to the interface, this guide explains how to create, analyze and design a model step-by-step. You should be able to ...
    • ProtaStructure Suite - New Features by Versions

      Thank you for choosing Prota as your technology partner. ProtaStructure Suite is an engineering solution with high technical content, including powerful features that put you ahead of your competitors. ProtaStructure is actively developed, and new ...